[The Brazil Times nameplate] Overcast ~ 53°F  
High: 58°F ~ Low: 47°F
Monday, May 2, 2016

Commissioners award bridge work, discuss specifications

Friday, March 27, 2009

After some deliberation, the Clay County Commissioners awarded work on two bridge projects.

In a special meeting Thursday, the commissioners questioned representatives from Allender Trucking, Inc., Brazil, who provided the lowest quotes on the projects -- one is Bridge No. 245 in Lewis Township on County Road 400 West, 0.2 miles north of CR 1350 S, and the other is located on CR 1300 N., near CR 450 W -- during a separate special meeting Monday.

The commissioners had tabled the issue in order to learn more about the company, because it is the first quotes they had submitted, before awarding the work.

"I'm not doubting your work, I just would like to know more about your company to make sure you have the ability to do the work," Commissioners' President Charlie Brown said.

Clay County Highway Superintendent Pete Foster also had his own hesitations about hiring Allender without knowing their abilities.

"I'm looking out for the people of Clay County and we have got to watch what we are doing here," Foster said. "We've taken it for granted for so many years that we had two companies doing most of the bridge work."

Commissioner Paul Sinders proceeded to ask a line of questions regarding the scope of work provided in the request for quotes and if Allender had the necessary equipment and an adequate understanding of the quote.

While Bryan Allender, owner of Allender Trucking, Inc., said his company did have the right equipment and understood what the project entailed, there was a new hitch his company had never encountered.

"We do have experience putting bridges in, but we have never put in a flat car," Allender said.

Brown expressed that Allender's lack of experience with flat cars was a concern, along with how the scopes are not specific enough.

However, Sinders said he felt Allender had the experience and ability to get the job done.

"Every company we've had put a flat car in was their first and everyone has to start somewhere," he said. "You can't necessarily put a knock on them just because they haven't done something before, plus I think they are bringing good experience to the table."

While the commissioners unanimously approved to accept the quotes from Allender, Brown emphasized he felt the scope of work provided needs to be analyzed.

"Maybe we need to include a drawing approximating what the bridge should look like when it is finished," he said. "We have a good base to work from at this time, but we need to tweak it. We're not engineers and I would like to emphasize that I don't have a problem with the workers, but with the specifications."

Brown also suggested the possibility of no longer using flat cars to replace bridges, which Sinders emphatically disputed.

"I think it is a safe and cost-effective way to do things in Clay County," Sinders said. "When FEMA (Federal Emergency Management Agency) was here after the flood, they were very impressed with what we are doing, and they can be tough to work with at times. Typically, they would only reimburse work that brings something back to its initial state and we had to sell them on the idea of improving on what we had and they agreed."

Meanwhile, the commissioners approved, and signed, a contract with Hannum, Wagle and Cline Engineering, Terre Haute, to get started on the USDA Rural Enterprise Grant Rail Study.

Sinders said the contract approval comes at a great time to allow Hannum, Wagle and Cline to conduct flyovers of the area to take pictures before leaves begin to appear on trees.

The next regular meeting of the Clay County Commissioners will be Monday, April 6, at 9 a.m., in the Commissioners' Courtroom at the Clay County Courthouse.

Note: The nature of the Internet makes it impractical for our staff to review every comment. If you feel that a comment is offensive, please Login or Create an account first, and then you will be able to flag a comment as objectionable. Please also note that those who post comments on thebraziltimes.com may do so using a screen name, which may or may not reflect a website user's actual name. Readers should be careful not to assign comments to real people who may have names similar to screen names. Refrain from obscenity in your comments, and to keep discussions civil, don't say anything in a way your grandmother would be ashamed to read.

I am a local business man in Clay County and have submitted bids on many projects, some of these I have not been awarded because I was not the lowest bidder. I have had business dealings with both Allender Trucking and Brown Land Improvements. I believe both are perfectly capable companies. I would be extremely unhappy with a county commissioner with no excavating or engineering experience making uneducated comments in the local paper about my company's competence and abilities to do a professional job; especially, when one of the companies bidding on these projects doesn't even own any equipment capable of doing any of these projects. My tax dollars and your tax dollars are involved in this. I hope people understand what is really going on and see there money is not necessarily being spent wisely!

-- Posted by michael78 on Sun, Mar 29, 2009, at 10:35 AM

Seems there are several red flags with this decision. Remember the weight room that was built at Northview a few years ago as it was awarded to a "buddy" of a school board member? Then it had to be built all over again as it wasn't built properly so we paid for two weight rooms at Northview. I would like to see some safeguards put into this project to insure that the county won't be doing this over again as well. I am not saying that this is or isn't a good ole boy deal but seems this county would have learned by now that if all the homework isn't done, it will end up costing more in the end. Remember you get what you pay for. While it is nice to give jobs to local people, people in the next county or state are just as worthy and if they have better track record and equipment to do the job, they should be considered. I for one will remember the location of those bridges just as I have that weight room...Just because you know the builder and he is "nice" guy, doesn't mean he is best person for the job. This kind of thing happens too much in this county which is part of the reason it is in the state it is in, in the first place. Too many "nice" people remaining in positions where they are not doing their jobs and people in administration confused or unable to judge performance as they think they are judging the person.

-- Posted by Jenny Moore on Mon, Mar 30, 2009, at 7:58 AM

Respond to this story

Posting a comment requires free registration: