[The Brazil Times nameplate] Fair ~ 69°F  
High: 74°F ~ Low: 49°F
Friday, May 6, 2016

Education remains a top concern

Sunday, March 20, 2011

State Representative Robert Heaton (Republican, District 46) answers a question during the Clay County Cracker Barrel Saturday as moderator Marshall Nuckolls looks on. Jason Moon Photo. [Order this photo]
* Legislators address questions during third Cracker Barrel

For the second time in as many months, education topped the list of Cracker Barrel concerns.

The third Clay County Cracker Barrel of 2011 took place Saturday at the YMCA of Clay County. The sessions are co-sponsored by the Clay County Chamber of Commerce and the Clay County Farm Bureau.

Indiana Representatives Jim Baird (Republican, District 44) and Robert Heaton (R-District 46) were in attendance, along with Senator Richard Bray (R-District 37).

Senator John Waterman (R-District 39) and Representative Clyde Kersey (Democrat, District 43) did not attend.

Baird, Heaton and Bray provided updates to the 81 in attendance prior to fielding questions.

"Certainly, these are unprecedented times," Baird said, referring to several House Democrats walking out of the legislative process.

Baird, however, said he was pleased the House Ways and Means Committee has proposed a balanced budget that preserves education funding and adds no new taxes.

"The (Democrats) walked out Feb. 22," Heaton added. "A lot of things have been stalled. But we need to continue to move forward."

Heaton also expressed concern for education, saying he was frustrated that larger school corporations receive more tax money.

"Why is there a difference per student," he asked.

Bray said while the House has had its share of problems, things were different for the Senate.

"In the Senate, things have been less exciting," he said. "But things are beginning to come to a standstill, which is very unfortunate and irresponsible. It's beginning to become more and more serious. We cannot allow the state to come to a standstill."

The trio of legislators fielded several questions from members of the audience Saturday, but the majority of them centered on education.

A handful of questions revolved around House Bill 1003, which would allow an increase of tax monies being used for charter schools.

One resident asked the legislators if there were a cap on the amount of money that could be used for a voucher, would the remaining money stay with the school corporation.

While the three appeared in agreement, another attendee asked Clay Community School Corporation (CCSC) Curriculum Director Kathy Knust to address the crowd and legislators.

"You're voting on the bill. You're the ones that need to know the answers," Knust said, adding she believed they didn't have full answers. "That is frightening."

Knust also expressed frustration regarding Indiana Superintendent of Public Instruction Tony Bennett.

"He's supposed to guide us and give us support," Knust said. "He is the Superintendent of Public Instruction, not the Superintendent of Private Instruction. He should support us first."

Heaton said there were several amendments surrounding the bill and with several House Democrats recently leaving the state, discussion on the bill has stalled.

"This is a process," Heaton said. "I appreciate your comments, but this is about the process."

Heaton also said charter schools are public schools and tax dollars are already filtered in them.

"It's tough," he said. "We understand the pain. We need to do all we can to help (students). It all boils down to helping every pupil, not just a few of them."

CCSC School Board member Ron Scherb asked the three if they were aware public vouchers had been declared unconstitutional in other states.

Scherb said he believed the problem with education centered on specific areas of the state and asked if something could be done for those areas only.

"You're changing everything statewide," Scherb said.

"As a state representative, I represent the state of Indiana, not just my district," Heaton said. "If we're doing a fine job, why would we change anything?"

Baird added he didn't want the system to be "patch worked."

Clay County Council representative Rita Rothrock asked if Clay County tax dollars would be put to use for charter schools in other areas. If not, the money, she said, would be put to use and should be put to use in Clay County.

Bray responded by saying county property taxes stay within the county and expressed frustration that some counties, such as Marion, received more tax money per student than other counties.

Another resident asked the three if a referendum vote could be applied to HB 1003. A referendum is, essentially, a ballot question.

"I personally would support the public to have greater input," Baird said.

Meanwhile, another resident asked if they were aware that tax money was going to inmates in order to provide further education.

Bray said this shouldn't be the case and added he would look into the issue.

"I'm opposed to this and if this is happening, it will stop," Bray said.

Moderator and Farm Bureau representative Marshall Nuckolls reminded the audience another Cracker Barrel could be scheduled in the future.

Note: The nature of the Internet makes it impractical for our staff to review every comment. If you feel that a comment is offensive, please Login or Create an account first, and then you will be able to flag a comment as objectionable. Please also note that those who post comments on thebraziltimes.com may do so using a screen name, which may or may not reflect a website user's actual name. Readers should be careful not to assign comments to real people who may have names similar to screen names. Refrain from obscenity in your comments, and to keep discussions civil, don't say anything in a way your grandmother would be ashamed to read.

I'm surprised that none of the elected officials did not state that with the recent change in the way the General Fund is funded, by the state using the 1% sales tax plus other state taxes vice a local tax levy, every citizen of Indiana has a stake in every school corporation within the state. Local property taxes from levies for the Capital Projects Fund, Transportation Fund, and the Bus Replacement Fund, which are truly local funds, stay within the corporation although a charter school may be able to draw off some of the Transportation Fund or have the school corporation provide some transportation in some cases if all proposed legislation becomes law.

I must disagree with Representative Heaton on the definition of charter schools as public schools. While charter schools are publicly-funded schools, they do not operate as do public schools nor are they required to engage the public in their operation. While current law gives oversight of a charter school to the sponsoring university's Board of Trustees, in whose selection a few parents might have a vote but none are required by law to have, proposed legislation (HB 1002) would change sponsorship to allow the state charter school board to sponsor charter schools statewide, thus removing any local control by parents. Current law (IC 20-24-6-5) requires that a teacher in a charter school hold a license to teach in a public school or be in the process of obtaining such a license; however, HB 1488 would allow 49% of teachers in a charter school to be unlicensed. For these reasons and others, both in current law and in proposed legislation, I must wholeheartedly disagree that charter schools are public schools.

-- Posted by Leo L. Southworth on Mon, Mar 21, 2011, at 7:20 AM

Mr. Heaton I disagree with you, you do not represent the entire state of Indiana! You were elected to represent the 46th district. If you want to represent the entire state than run for U.S. Senate!!!

-- Posted by Partrosie on Mon, Mar 21, 2011, at 11:27 AM

Thank You Partrosie! Heaton's comment made the hair on my arms stand up. This guy is in an elected office for the 46th district but , in his own mind, he's a U.S. Rep. Would someone pull Mr. Basketball aside and explain it to him!

-- Posted by reddevil on Tue, Mar 22, 2011, at 10:47 PM

Respond to this story

Posting a comment requires free registration: